Contact Us (844) 640-6100

Blog

AI and Your Family Law Case: What Virginia and DC Families Should Know

Posted by Gabrielle A. Best Husband | Nov 16, 2026 | 0 Comments

AI and Your Family Law Case: What Virginia and DC Families Should Know - G. Best Husband Law, PLLC

Artificial intelligence has found its way into almost every part of daily life, and family law is no exception. More and more people ask a chatbot about divorce, custody, or support before they ever speak with a lawyer. Photos, text messages, and even voices can now be created or changed in minutes. Courts in Virginia and Washington, DC are working through what all of this means for evidence, for court filings, and for privacy.

I want to share what I am watching most closely, and what you can do to protect yourself and your children. My goal is not to scare you away from technology. It is to help you use it wisely when so much is at stake.

Deepfakes and Altered Evidence

Text messages, photos, voicemails, and videos often play a central role in custody, divorce, and protective order cases. Today, AI tools can fabricate or alter all of them. A made-up text thread, an edited photo, or a cloned voice can look and sound convincing.

Before evidence can be considered in a Virginia court, the person offering it must authenticate it. Under Virginia Rule of Evidence 2:901, that means offering evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what that person claims it is. The federal Advisory Committee on Evidence Rules has spent much of 2026 studying whether new rules are needed for AI-generated evidence and deepfakes. As of its October 2026 meeting, no new federal rule on deepfakes had been approved, so courts continue to rely on the existing authentication rules.

What this means for you: keep original files, not just screenshots. Save messages in the app where you received them, keep the phone or device, and do not edit, crop, or filter anything you may want to use as evidence. If you believe the other side has offered something fake, tell your attorney right away. Questions about authenticity can sometimes call for a forensic review.

Your Chatbot Is Not Your Lawyer: Privilege and Discovery

This is the point I most want every client to hear. What you put into an AI tool, including your prompts, the documents you upload, and the chat history that follows, may not stay private. In litigation, that information may be discoverable, and it is likely not protected by the attorney-client privilege.

The attorney-client privilege protects confidential communications between you and your lawyer for the purpose of getting legal advice. A chatbot is not a lawyer. In February 2026, in United States v. Heppner, a federal judge in New York ruled that a defendant's written exchanges with a publicly available AI platform were not protected by the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine. The court explained that the AI platform is not an attorney, and that its privacy policy allowed the company to collect user data and disclose it to third parties, so the defendant could not have had a reasonable expectation of confidentiality. The court also held that sending the AI-generated documents to his lawyer afterward did not make them privileged.

Heppner was a federal criminal case, and I am not aware of a Virginia or DC court that has ruled on this question in a family law case. Its reasoning is still a strong warning. Discovery rules are broad. In Virginia, Rule 4:1(b)(1) generally allows discovery of any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the subject matter of the case. Even the leaders of AI companies have acknowledged the issue. In July 2025, OpenAI chief executive Sam Altman publicly said that ChatGPT conversations do not have the legal confidentiality that applies to conversations with a lawyer, a doctor, or a therapist, and that the company could be required to produce them in a lawsuit.

Picture a parent who asks a chatbot how to keep the children away from the other parent, or a spouse who uploads bank statements and asks how to make income look smaller. In a custody or support case, those words could end up in front of a judge. Before you type, ask yourself whether you would be comfortable with a judge reading it. A few practical rules:

  • Keep confidential details, financial records, and your attorney's advice out of public AI tools.
  • Do not paste emails or letters from your attorney into a chatbot to have them summarized. Sharing legal advice with a third party can put the privilege at risk.
  • Do not delete existing chats or messages once a case is underway or expected. Destroying potential evidence can create serious problems of its own, so ask your attorney what to keep.
  • Bring your legal questions to your attorney, where the conversation is protected.

When AI Gets the Law Wrong

Generative AI tools are designed to produce text that sounds right. They do not always produce text that is right. When a tool invents a case or a quote, it is often called a “hallucination,” and courts are taking these errors seriously.

The case that first drew national attention was Mata v. Avianca, Inc., where a federal judge in New York sanctioned two lawyers and their firm $5,000 in 2023 for filing a brief that relied on fake cases generated by ChatGPT. Closer to home, in August 2026, the Court of Appeals of Virginia found that a brief in LPC Commercial Services, LLC v. Ar-Razzaaq Properties, LLC contained 25 “phantom quotes” attributed to Virginia cases and directed the attorney to complete a continuing legal education course. In September 2026, the District of Columbia Court of Appeals struck a brief that cited nonexistent cases in Douglas v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Co. and referred the matter to the D.C. Bar's Office of Disciplinary Counsel.

Courts are also setting rules. In January 2026, the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond adopted a local rule requiring attorneys and pro se litigants to disclose the use of AI in their filings, and the Amherst County Circuit Court adopted a similar rule in March 2026. In DC, the courts created a standing Artificial Intelligence Task Force in March 2026, and one of its assignments is to develop court rules on disclosure, accuracy, authenticity, and certification of AI use. Requirements can differ from court to court, so it is important to check the local rules in each case.

These rules matter even if you are representing yourself. A self-represented party who relies on a chatbot for case law or court procedure faces the same risk of filing something that is simply wrong, and the Richmond rule applies to self-represented parties too.

AI and Co-Parenting Messages

Many separated parents communicate through co-parenting apps, email, or text. Some apps and phones now offer tools that suggest rewording or help draft a message. Used thoughtfully, these tools can help a parent stay calm and child-focused when emotions run high.

Keep in mind that you are responsible for every message you send, no matter who or what helped write it. Messages between parents are often offered as evidence in custody cases. Read every AI suggestion before you hit send, make sure it says what you actually mean, and never let a tool make promises or agreements on your behalf. If a message from the other parent suddenly sounds nothing like them, save it and mention it to your attorney.

How I Use Technology in My Practice

Technology can make legal work more efficient, and I welcome tools that help me serve my clients well. The ethics guidance in both of my jurisdictions is clear that the lawyer remains responsible for the work. In Ethics Opinion 388, the D.C. Bar advised that lawyers who use generative AI must understand its risks, protect client confidential information, and review and verify AI output before relying on it. The Virginia State Bar has addressed AI as well, including Legal Ethics Opinion 1901, approved by the Supreme Court of Virginia in November 2025.

In my practice, that means every citation is checked, client confidences stay protected, and no software replaces the judgment and care your family deserves. Your case deserves a person who knows your story, not just a program that predicts words.

A Quick AI Checklist for Your Family Law Case

Whether your case is just beginning or already underway, I encourage you to:

  • Keep original messages, photos, and recordings on the device where they were created or received.
  • Avoid editing, filtering, or cropping anything you may want to use as evidence.
  • Keep confidential details and your attorney's advice out of public AI tools.
  • Assume anything you type into a chatbot could someday be read in court.
  • Talk with your attorney before deleting any AI chats, texts, or app messages.
  • Read every AI-suggested message before you send it to your co-parent.
  • Tell your attorney right away if you suspect that evidence has been altered or fabricated.

How We Can Help

Divorce, custody, and support cases are never only about the law. They are about your family, your finances, and your future. With more than a decade of family law experience, I help clients in Fairfax County, Arlington County, Alexandria, Prince William County, and Washington, DC navigate new challenges like these with care and a clear plan.

If you have questions about evidence, privacy, or technology in your divorce, custody, or support case, please reach out. Call G. Best Husband Law, PLLC at (844) 640-6100, email [email protected], or schedule a consultation online at gbesthusbandlaw.com. Together, we can protect what matters most to you and your children.

G. Best Husband Law, PLLC. Conscientious and Committed.

This post is for general information only and is not legal advice. Laws and court rules on artificial intelligence are changing quickly, and every situation is different, so please speak with a family law attorney about your own circumstances.

About the Author

Gabrielle A. Best Husband

Divorce & Family Law Attorney | G. Best Husband Law, PLLC Discreet, high-caliber divorce and family law services in Northern Virginia and D.C. Schedule a confidential consultation with Gabrielle A. Best Husband today.

Comments

There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Menu